Backlinking mistakes remain one of the fastest ways to destroy your search engine rankings. In this transcript from Episode 083, Mark answers a listener question about changing WordPress themes and shares an SEO tip from Alex Miller of the Rankings Institute about the link-building practices that are killing money sites.
What You'll Learn in This Episode
- How to safely change WordPress themes without losing rankings or traffic
- Why mass-generated backlinks are destroying money sites
- The low-volume, high-quality link strategy that actually works
- Tools and techniques for monitoring site performance during a theme change
Listener Question: How to Change WordPress Themes Safely
Chris from NicheSiteTools.com asks about migrating from Thesis 1.8.5 to a mobile-responsive theme. Mark shares his perspective on the WordPress theme landscape and offers concrete advice for making the switch without losing rankings.
Mark's theme recommendations: Genesis, WooThemes, and Elegant Themes all offer strong responsive design options. While Thesis remains a solid framework for developers, its usability for non-technical users declined with version 2.0. For people getting started in internet marketing and building websites, the newer frameworks are significantly easier to work with.
Protecting your SEO during a theme change: The biggest risk is that a new theme will alter your title tags or meta descriptions. Title tags are what appear in Google search results, and if your new theme appends your site name to every page title or makes other changes, it can negatively impact your rankings. Mark recommends using the Yoast SEO Plugin to override any theme-level SEO settings and maintain control over title tags and descriptions.
Watch for duplicate content: Themes can create archive pages, category pages, and author pages that essentially republish your posts. Google treats duplicate content within your own site as spammy. When switching themes, verify that these additional pages are either disabled or set to noindex so that each piece of content appears only once in Google's index.
Monitor user behavior: Pat Flynn saw a dramatic decrease in key engagement metrics when he switched the Smart Passive Income theme. Before changing themes, make sure Google Analytics is properly installed so you can track changes in time on site, click-through rates, and opt-in conversions. Mark also recommends CrazyEgg, a heat mapping tool that shows exactly where visitors are clicking, so you can compare behavior before and after the switch.
SEO Tips from Alex Miller at Rankings Institute
Alex Miller runs an SEO firm that serves other SEO firms, giving him access to ranking data across hundreds or thousands of client websites. Unlike most SEO commentators who speculate about what works, Alex bases his advice on aggregate data across many niches and campaigns.
Stop mass linking to money sites immediately. If you are building links to your money site using software-generated mass links, you are killing your rankings. This includes mass article submissions, mass directory submissions, and mass social bookmarks. Those “500 bookmarks for five dollars” services are among the worst things you can order for a site you care about.
If you must do directory submissions or social bookmarking, do them manually and in low volume. Instead of 500 automated social bookmarks, submit manually to five of the most authoritative bookmarking sites. The only exception to the mass-link rule is press releases, because press release sites tend to carry higher authority.
A low volume of high-quality links beats thousands of junk links. Alex's data shows that sites can dominate rankings with as few as 50 to 100 quality backlinks. The best links are guest posts acquired through manual blog outreach. Guest posts on high page-rank sites have always been powerful, and that has not changed. The effort required is greater, but the results are dramatically better than any mass-linking approach.
Key Takeaways
- When changing WordPress themes, protect your title tags with Yoast SEO and watch for duplicate content from archive and category pages
- Monitor analytics before and after any theme change so you can detect problems quickly
- Mass-generated backlinks are actively hurting money sites, not helping them
- Focus on acquiring a small number of high-quality guest post links rather than thousands of automated links
- Base your SEO decisions on data, not speculation
What's Changed Since This Episode
Mark recorded this in October 2014. The core advice about quality over quantity in link building has only become more important.
Thesis, WooThemes, and Elegant Themes have all evolved significantly. The Genesis framework from StudioPress remains popular and was acquired by WP Engine. Elegant Themes became known primarily for their Divi builder. WooThemes was acquired by Automattic and became WooCommerce, focusing on e-commerce rather than general themes. The WordPress theme landscape now includes full site editing with block themes, though classic themes remain widely used.
Google's link quality standards have become even stricter. The advice Alex gave in 2014 about avoiding mass links was ahead of the curve. Google's subsequent algorithm updates, including multiple Penguin refreshes and the eventual integration of Penguin into the core algorithm in 2016, made low-quality link building even more dangerous. In 2026, Google's spam detection is far more sophisticated, and the emphasis on high-quality, editorially earned links is stronger than ever.
Mobile responsiveness is no longer optional. Chris's question about switching to a responsive theme was prescient. Google implemented mobile-first indexing across all sites, making responsive design a baseline requirement rather than a nice-to-have feature.
Resources Mentioned
- Yoast SEO Plugin — WordPress SEO management
- Genesis Framework — WordPress theme framework
- Elegant Themes — WordPress themes
- CrazyEgg — heat mapping and user behavior analytics
Related Episodes
If you found this episode helpful, you might also enjoy:
- LNIM083 Show Notes — Are Backlinking Mistakes Killing Your SEO?
- LNIM082 Transcript — Affiliate Marketing Success Stories
- Google Penguin 3.0 Update — What You Need to Know
Listen and Subscribe
Listen to Late Night Internet Marketing on Apple Podcasts or subscribe at latenightim.com/internet-marketing-podcast/. Have a question for Mark? Call the digital recorder at 214-444-8655 or drop a comment below.
